Gateshead are set to confirm the return of one of their former managers, after a move for Andy Butler broke down within hours of their league defeat against Barrow.
The Heed were heavily linked with a move for the former Scunthorpe United manager, prior to Saturday’s league game – with Butler himself being in attendance ahead of his move to the troubled National League outfit.
However, within hours of the final whistle, it was reported that a move for him had broken down without a reason provided, forcing Gateshead to go back to the drawing board once again.
Gateshead set to welcome back former manager
After missing out on Butler, Gateshead have now identified their idea successor for Lee Cattermole, and that is set to involve a familiar face returning to the dugouts once again.
According to a report from journalist Pete O’Rourke, the Heed are set to confirm the return of former manager Alun Armstrong as their new first-team manager for a second stint.
The 51-year-old is currently the Head of Football Development with the National League side, after taking on the role following confirmation that he relinquished his position as manager back in January.
Armstrong was appointed back in June 2025, taking over from Carl Magnay, but lost 20 of his 32 matches in charge of the club and departed his position with the club rock bottom of the table.
Since his departure, the club had to be saved from relegation by a returning Rob Elliot, before moving on to Cattermole after the former left for fellow National League side Carlisle United.
Is this a good move for the club?
Gateshead are the subject of a pending takeover at present, after being saved mere days before the club faced heavy HMRC sanctions and the likelihood of dissolving.
However, with that takeover not yet confirmed officially, the Heed have to focus on matters on the pitch, where they currently find themselves bottom of the table after taking just four points from their opening 16 league matches and are already being cut adrift.
There is no denial that Armstrong knows the football club strongly, having managed the first-team, U19s and leading the Academy’s development – but he struggled during his first stint in charge and the situation he enters now is more challenging.
The football club have played almost half of the season already and are 13 points off safety, having scored just nine goals all campaign and have the second-worst defence to match.
Given their current league position, Gateshead’s supporters may have had their eyes on someone that can help to keep the team up – rather than taking a risk and going back to a manager who’s previous stint was unsuccessful and almost resulted in their relegation back to the sixth-tier.
The report also confirms that former Sunderland and Newcastle United midfielder Paul Bracewell will be arriving as the new Director of Football – suggesting that the club’s proposed new owners are beginning to build foundations behind the scenes.
Therefore, one could argue that the appointment of Armstrong will be focussed more on helping with familiarity and trying to use the experienced knowledge of the club to try and get the best out of what they have – rather than hiring someone that doesn’t know the club and is likely to want to make wholesale changes in a short period of time, possibly leaving the club even worse off further down the line.


